Portraits of Italians in health affairs in 19th century Istanbul: Dr. Castaldi, Pharmacist A. Calleja, Midwife Messani", in: Mirella Galletti (editor), Medici, missionari, musicisti militari italiani attivi in Persia, Impero Ottomano ed Egitto, Quaderni di Oriente Moderno Roma, Istituto per l'Oriente C.A. Nallino,
Quaderni di Oriente Moderno, cilt.88, sa.6, ss.135-149, 2008 (Hakemli Dergi)
- Yayın Türü: Makale / Tam Makale
- Cilt numarası: 88 Sayı: 6
- Basım Tarihi: 2008
- Dergi Adı: Quaderni di Oriente Moderno
- Sayfa Sayıları: ss.135-149
- Açık Arşiv Koleksiyonu: AVESİS Açık Erişim Koleksiyonu
- Acıbadem Mehmet Ali Aydınlar Üniversitesi Adresli: Hayır
Özet
Portraits of Italians in Health Affairs in 19th
century Istanbul,
(Dr. Castaldi, Pharmacist A. Calleja, Midwife Messani)*
Yesim Isil Ulman**
Turkish - Italian Relations through history up to the 19th century
The first European language heard by
Turks settling in Anatolia after 1071 was the Italian of Genoese and Venetian
merchants[1].
While borrowing many words from each other, the cross-cultural relationships of
the two communities in commerce, maritime, politics, history and medicine
continued for ages. Actually Galata, then mostly a Genoese colony, and the
liveliest trade centre in Constantinople of the pre-modern era, had existed for
years in the capital city as an autonomous administrative unit independent from
the Paleologos dynasty during the late Byzantine Empire[2].
Galata was one of the oldest and most powerful colonies of the Italian
city-states. When Constantinople was conquered by the Sultan Mehmed II in 1453,
Italian city states were enjoying the heyday of their influence and power in
the East. Sultan Mehmed II (the Conqueror, 1451-1481) neither lay siege to or
invaded the region, nor did he hesitate to recognize the rights and privileges
of Galata’s inhabitants[3],
[4]. As a
matter of fact, the Ottoman State, as the main successor of Eastern Roman
Empire, continued all its relations with the Italian city-states, both in
political and commercial transactions as well as cultural and scientific
exchanges[5]. This
action was quite compatible with the Ottoman style of expansion in recognizing
the rights of conquered local communities by allowing them freedom in their
private and social lives, commercial activities, and religious worship while
protecting them with imperial power. But the communities were required to pay
regular taxes in return. As the Ottoman officials gleaned a very considerable
profit from the trade, merchandise, and customs at Galata, they even encouraged
and promoted the growth of Italian (and
other foreign) settlements in Galata and Pera[6].
Foreign influences increased in variety over the course of time, particularly
in Pera where foreign legations and residences emerged and a European and
elegant way of living flourished. Until the 19th century, it seems that Italian
influence had gradually waned especially compared with French presence in
the intellectual and cultural centres of
Constantinople. Similarly French became the most preferred language in the
press and scientific publications.
* I would like to thank Prof. Dr.
A.M. Piemontese and Associate Prof. Dr. Mirella Galletti for the accomplishment
of this interactive and cross-cultural academic work. I am also thankful to
Prof. A. Cadonna and Fondazione Cini in Venice-Italy for hosting the scientific
meeting preceding the articles.
** MA, MSc, Ph.D. Associate
Professor at Istanbul University, Cerrahpasa Faculty of Medicine, Department of
Medical History and Ethics, Istanbul-TURKEY. E-mail: yesimul@yahoo.com
[1] Oguz
Karakartal, “Türk kültüründe Italyancaya bir bakis”, Tarih ve Toplum, No.152, August 1996, p.44.
[2]
Mantran, 17.yy.in ikinci yarisinda
Istanbul, vol.2, Ankara 1990, p.117.
[3] This
action was well compatible with the Ottoman philosophy of expansion which was
mainly based on setting the communities she conquered free in their social,
religious, cultural, private actions to maintain in their social life as
before. In return the nations were imposed to give taxes to the Sublime Porte
and Ibid.
vol.1, p.71-72.
[4] See:
“Privilege granted to the Genoese colony of Galata by Mehmed the Conqueror,
08.06.1453 (Ahidname dating 30 Cemaziulahir 857) cited by Edhem Eldem
and Carla Pestana, “Mechanism of Empire”, Workshop on Ottoman and Atlantic
Empires in the Early Modern World, Istanbul October 19-20, 2005.
[5]Orhan
Kologlu, “Italian contributions to Ottoman medicine and pharmacology”, Proceedings of 38th international congress
on history of medicine, ed. N.Sari, A.H.Bayat, Y.I.Ulman, M.Isin, TTK yay.
Ankara, 2006;2:1013-1020.
[6] “The
contact between Venice and Ottomans: merchants”, by Ugo Tucci, summarised by
F.M.Cosar, Toplumsal Tarih, vol.1,
No.2, February 1996, p.17.